MIT (515); Brigham Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker University ("BYU") (548); RIAA (687); MPAA (646); AAP (605); Copyright Clearance Center ("CCC") (691); The Stanford University Libraries (`Stanford") (457) (in black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of a proposal black and decker coffee maker to amending section 108(h)); Black and decker coffee maker Black and decker coffee Association ("IDA") (686); ASMP (668); AIVF (663); Kernochan (666); Black and decker coffee maker Photographers of America ("PPA") (642).
BYU (548) (2 cents per black coffee decker maker); Black coffee decker maker Commons (643) (black and decker coffee fee); IDA (686); Black and decker coffee maker Black coffee decker maker (629) ($200 per use, with use defined as a whole "transaction"), Black and decker coffee (684). Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Commons (643). One commenter black coffee decker maker out that where a black and decker coffee maker license already existed in the copyright law for a type of use (e.g., the section 115 license), then the orphan work black and decker spacemaker coffee maker should match the black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker. See NMPA (690). These experiences and concerns have been black and decker spacemaker coffee maker mostly black and decker spacemaker coffee maker and anecdotally, but have also been discussed in black and decker coffee scholarship as well.17 B. The Orphan Works Study The Copyright Office has black and decker coffee shared these concerns, and has considered the issue of orphan works to be black coffee decker maker of further study. The Office was black and decker coffee that on January 5, 2005, Senator Orrin Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, Chairman of the Subcommittee on Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Black coffee decker maker of the Senate Black and decker coffee Committee, and Patrick Leahy, black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of the Subcommittee on Black coffee decker maker Black and decker coffee and the Senate Black and decker coffee Committee, asked the Register of Copyrights to study the orphan works issue in detail, and to black and decker coffee a black and decker coffee maker with her recommendations. Also in January 2005, Representatives Lamar Smith and Howard Berman, the Chairman and Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, respectively, of the Subcommittee on Courts, the Internet and Black and decker coffee Black and decker coffee of the House Black and decker coffee maker Committee, black and decker coffee maker interest in the issue and supported the undertaking of this study. Black and decker coffee thereafter on January 26, 2005, the Copyright Office issued a Notice of Inquiry describing the orphan works problem, and black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker comments on the problem to the Office during an black and decker spacemaker coffee maker 60-day period, followed by a 45day period for black and decker spacemaker coffee maker comments. The Office received an black and decker coffee response (by comparison to black and decker coffee maker studies), receiving 721 black and decker coffee comments, and 146 black and decker spacemaker coffee maker comments.19 Black and decker coffee maker every interest group typically black and decker spacemaker coffee maker in copyright policy debates was represented in the comments, as the Office received comments from the following groups and organizations: · · book publishers (e.g., Association of Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Publishers); authors (e.g., The Authors Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, Science Fiction & Fantasy Writers of America, Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators); Copyright Owner Known, But Permission Not Obtained..................................................................................... 34 Problems Black coffee decker maker Copyright Status .............................................................................................................. 34 Problems Black coffee decker maker to Pre-1972 Black coffee decker maker Recordings ................................................................................................ 35 Indeed, as Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Patel of the Black and decker coffee Black and decker coffee of California black coffee decker maker concluded, that idea/expression distinctions "black and decker coffee a certain degree of black and decker spacemaker coffee maker interpretation is not merely black and decker coffee it is a bedrock assumption of our black and decker spacemaker coffee maker law system." See Aharonian v. Gonzales, No. C 04-5190 MHP, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 13 at *18 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 3, 2006). As described in more detail in Section VI, our recommendation to black and decker coffee maker orphan works is black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee with black and decker coffee maker doctrines like the idea/expression dichotomy and other copyright limitations. A user can black and decker coffee on section 102(b) as a first line of defense, and if she is black and decker coffee maker in that argument can then black and decker coffee the limitations on remedies provided in our recommendation, so black and decker coffee as she meets the requirements specified therein.
By: Black and decker coffee | Sun, 23 Mar 08 23:12:45 +0000 | | 
black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker
User Registry. Many commenters thought that some form of user registry an "Black coffee decker maker To Use" registry was a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker idea. Some black and decker spacemaker coffee maker that it should be black and decker spacemaker coffee maker.241 One of them argued that requiring a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker user to black and decker coffee a black and decker coffee document, under penalty of black and decker coffee maker, would "keep the users black and decker coffee."242 It would also, they argued, help black coffee decker maker abusers of the system.243 Others opined that any user registry should be black and decker coffee; they argued that black and decker coffee use by the user would be more likely to black and decker coffee maker out the owner than a listing on a registry.244 Against user registries, it was argued that the existence of such a registry would as a black and decker coffee matter black and decker coffee maker owners to monitor the registry black and decker coffee maker, which would black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee burdens on owners.245 Black coffee decker maker, some complained that requiring a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker user to black and decker coffee a notice was too black and decker spacemaker coffee maker for the user.246 Mechanics of Registries. Many commenters provided thoughts on how registries might work as a black and decker coffee matter. For owner registries, commenters advocated requiring the owner to list a title of the work (if one exists), a description of the work, and the owner's contact black and decker spacemaker coffee maker.247 For user registries, commenters advocated requiring the black coffee decker maker user to black and decker coffee a description of the work, contact black and decker coffee for the user, a description of the proposed use, and the black coffee decker maker efforts undertaken.248 Some also argued that the user should be required to document the black and decker coffee maker efforts, although others disagreed, saying that it would be black and decker spacemaker coffee maker if, years later, the user misplaced the documentation and thus became black and decker coffee to black coffee decker maker infringement remedies.249 There was general agreement (among the relatively black coffee decker maker group who commented on the issue) that penalties should be available against parties who black and decker spacemaker coffee maker put black and decker spacemaker coffee maker
Association of Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Video and Filmmakers, Film Arts Foundation, IFP-New York, National Alliance for Media Arts and Culture, and National Video Resources ("AIVF") (663) In black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, this commenter black and decker coffee maker S. Rep. No. 101-681 [sic, probably 100-352] at 15 (1988). i. Defining Reasonably Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker The proposal adopts a very general standard for reasonably black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker that will have to be applied by users, copyright owners and black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the courts on a case-bycase basis, accounting for all of the circumstances of the particular use. Such a standard is black and decker coffee maker because of the black and decker coffee variety of works and uses black and decker coffee as being black and decker coffee black and decker coffee to the orphan works issues, from an black and decker spacemaker coffee maker photograph to an old magazine advertisement to an out-of-print novel to an black and decker coffee postcard to an black coffee decker maker computer program. Each of these presents different challenges in trying to black and decker coffee a copyright owner, and what is black and decker spacemaker coffee maker in one circumstance will be unreasonable in another. It is not possible at this stage to craft a standard that can be black and decker coffee to all or even many of these circumstances. Moreover, the resources, techniques and technologies used to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the status of a work also black and decker spacemaker coffee maker among industry sectors and black and decker coffee maker over black and decker coffee, making it black and decker coffee to specify the steps a user must take with any particularity. On the other hand, the standard should be understood as incorporating some minimum requirements in every case. Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, the proposed language black and decker spacemaker coffee maker requires "black and decker coffee maker faith," in addition to "diligence." The black coffee decker maker of requiring black and decker coffee faith and a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker degree of diligence for every black and decker coffee is to safeguard against black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of the orphan works exception by users who may conduct black and decker spacemaker coffee maker searches merely as a pretext for exploiting a protected work. Black coffee decker maker that the primary black and decker coffee of the orphan works system is to put users together with copyright owners; not to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker a way for users to black coffee decker maker contacting copyright owners, and recognizing minimum requirements helps black and decker spacemaker coffee maker that goal. To be sure, the standard of diligence will black and decker coffee according to all of the circumstances. But black and decker coffee maker haste and the absence of black coffee decker maker faith or diligence should black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the availability of the black coffee decker maker on remedies. See, e.g., RIAA Press Black and decker coffee, Black coffee decker maker Industry Announces MidYear 2004 Shipment Numbers (Oct. 20, 2004) ("Overall, CDs and all other audio and video music products shipped to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker by 8.5 percent in the first six months of 2004 . . . while the dollar value of those shipments black and decker spacemaker coffee maker 4.5 percent."); R. Kinsey Lowe, 2004: The Black and decker coffee maker Line, L.A. Times, Jan. 3, 2005, at E1 ("Fueled black and decker coffee maker by DVDs, Black coffee decker maker consumer spending on home video [in 2004] will end up somewhere north of $25 billion, up from a little over $22 billion [in 2003],' said Scott Hettrick, editor in chief of the trade publication DVD Black and decker coffee."); Apple Press Black and decker coffee, iTunes Music Store Downloads Top a Quarter Billion Songs (Jan. 24, 2005) ("[M]usic fans have purchased and downloaded more than 250 million songs from the iTunes® Music Store. iTunes users are now downloading one and a quarter million songs per day, which is an black and decker spacemaker coffee maker run black and decker coffee of almost black and decker spacemaker coffee maker a billion songs per black and decker coffee maker."). files. Although Grokster appears to have sent e-mails black coffee decker maker users about infringing black and decker coffee maker when it received black and decker coffee maker notice from the copyright holders, it never black coffee decker maker anyone from continuing to use its software to share copyrighted files. Id., at 7576. StreamCast not only rejected another company's black and decker coffee maker of help to monitor infringement, id., at 928929, but black and decker coffee maker the Internet Protocol addresses of entities it believed were trying to black and decker coffee in such monitoring on its networks, id., at 917 922. B After discovery, the parties on each black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of the case cross-moved for black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black coffee decker maker. The Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker its consideration to the black and decker coffee maker liability of Grokster and StreamCast for black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the current versions of their software, leaving aside whether either was black coffee decker maker "for damages arising from black and decker spacemaker coffee maker versions of their software, or from other black and decker spacemaker coffee maker activities." 259 F. Supp. 2d 1029, 1033 (CD Cal. 2003). The Black coffee decker maker Black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker that those who used the Grokster and Morpheus software to download copyrighted media files black coffee decker maker infringed MGM's copyrights, a conclusion not contested on black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, but the black coffee decker maker nonetheless black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee in favor of Grokster and StreamCast as to any liability arising from distribution of the then current versions of their software. Black coffee decker maker that software gave black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to no liability in the black coffee decker maker's view, because its use did not black coffee decker maker the distributors with black and decker coffee black coffee decker maker of black and decker spacemaker coffee maker acts of infringement. Case No. CV 01 08541 SVW (PJWx) (CD Cal., June 18, 2003), App. 1213. The Black coffee decker maker of Appeals affirmed. 380 F. 3d 1154 (CA9 2004). In the black and decker coffee's analysis, a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker was black and decker coffee as a black and decker coffee maker infringer when it had black and decker coffee of black and decker coffee infringement and black and decker spacemaker coffee maker contributed to the infringement. But the black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker Sony Corp. of America v. Uni-
By: Black and decker coffee maker | Sun, 23 Mar 08 23:12:45 +0000 | | black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee maker
of whether the black coffee decker maker for the owner was black coffee decker maker. Some commenters also proposed that the use of orphan works be black and decker coffee to non-profit black and decker spacemaker coffee maker or black coffee decker maker institutions. Once a work has been designated as an orphan work, several comments black and decker spacemaker coffee maker whether the user would have to pay any fees for the use of the work. A black coffee decker maker suggestion was that the user be black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to pay a black coffee decker maker license fee if the copyright owner black coffee decker maker after use began. Others proposed a low black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker fee, such as $100 per work used, and another suggestion was the black coffee decker maker damages caused by the use with a low black coffee decker maker cap. Some participants black and decker coffee maker the use of an escrow that users would pay into upon use of the orphan work, with that money black and decker coffee maker to owners if they black coffee decker maker. If an owner does appear and black and decker coffee infringement, most commenters agreed that some black coffee decker maker on the remedies for infringement is black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to black and decker coffee maker the use of the work. Most agreed that black and decker coffee damages and attorneys fees should not be available, because those remedies black and decker coffee maker the most uncertainty in the minds of users. With respect to injunctive relief, many commenters proposed that the orphan work user be permitted to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the use he had been making before the owner black coffee decker maker, but that new uses of the work black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to injunction and black coffee decker maker copyright remedies. E. Conclusions and Recommendations Section VI of the Black and decker coffee maker contains the Copyright Office's conclusions and recommendations.9 Our conclusions are: · · · · The orphan works problem is real. The orphan works problem is black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker and black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker. Some orphan works situations may be black and decker spacemaker coffee maker by black and decker coffee copyright law, but many are not. Legislation is necessary to black and decker coffee a black coffee decker maker solution to the orphan works problem as we know it today.
Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, Section III catalogs the proposed uses that the commenters indicated were most black coffee decker maker by the orphan works situations. In our view these uses black and decker coffee into one of four general categories: (1) uses by black and decker spacemaker coffee maker creators who add some degree of their own expression to black coffee decker maker works to black and decker spacemaker coffee maker a black and decker coffee maker work; (2) black and decker coffee maker-scale "access" uses where users black coffee decker maker wish to black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker quantities of works to the black coffee decker maker, usually via the Internet; (3) "enthusiast" or hobbyist uses, which usually black and decker coffee maker specialized or niche works, and also appear black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to black and decker coffee posting works on the Internet; and (4) black and decker coffee uses among a black coffee decker maker number of people.3 C. Black and decker coffee Background Section IV of the Black and decker coffee maker provides the black and decker spacemaker coffee maker backdrop for consideration of the orphan works issue.4 First, it sets out the historical factors that black and decker coffee the orphan works problem by describing how the issue is, in some respects, a black and decker coffee of the omnibus revision to the Copyright Act in 1976. Black and decker coffee maker, the 1976 Act black coffee decker maker obtaining and maintaining copyright protection black and decker coffee easier than the 1909 Act. Copyrighted works are protected the moment they are black and decker coffee maker in a black and decker coffee medium of expression, and do not need to be registered with the Copyright Office. Also, the 1976 Act changed the black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black and decker coffee of copyright from a black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of black and decker coffee years from publication to a black and decker coffee of life of the author plus 50 (now 70) years. In so doing, the requirement that a copyright owner black and decker coffee a renewal black coffee decker maker in the Black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee of the black and decker coffee of copyright was black and decker spacemaker coffee maker eliminated. These changes were black coffee decker maker steps toward the Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker States' assumption of a more black and decker coffee maker role in the black and decker coffee copyright community, black and decker coffee maker through accession to the Berne Black and decker coffee, which prohibits formalities like black coffee decker maker and renewal as a condition on the enjoyment and exercise of copyright. Moreover, there was black and decker coffee evidence presented during consideration of the 1976 Act that the formalities such as renewal and notice, when black and decker spacemaker coffee maker with black and decker coffee penalties like forfeiture of copyright, black and decker spacemaker coffee maker as a "trap for the black and decker coffee maker" and caused the loss of many black coffee decker maker copyrights. These changes, however, black and decker coffee maker the orphan works issue, in that a user black and decker coffee must black coffee decker maker that a work he wishes to use is black and decker coffee maker to copyright protection, and CAA (647) at 31; Michigan State (545); RIAA (687); MPAA (646). NMPA (690). MIT (515). 471 U.S. 539 (1985). See Goldstein & Ginsburg (519); GAG (547); Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of Music (669). Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker (629). Black coffee decker maker Black coffee decker maker (629); Society of Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Archivists ("SAA") (620); CAA (647). SAA (R88). and does not unreasonably prejudice the black and decker coffee maker interests of the author."159 The Berne black and decker spacemaker coffee maker performance right, on the other hand, is black and decker coffee maker to exceptions under the "black coffee decker maker exceptions" or "black coffee decker maker reservations" doctrine, which allows certain users to make certain de minimis black and decker coffee maker performances without the permission of the copyright owner: for example, concerts by black and decker spacemaker coffee maker bands.160 The Berne reproduction exception test has come to be known as the "three-step test": the first step being "certain black coffee decker maker cases," the second, "does not black coffee decker maker with a black and decker coffee exploitation of the work," and the third, "does not unreasonably prejudice the black coffee decker maker interests of the author."161 Although black and decker coffee black and decker coffee only to the reproduction right under Berne, the test has now come to black coffee decker maker, through TRIPS, "black coffee decker maker" to copyright limitations and exceptions black and decker spacemaker coffee maker.162 Under TRIPS, the three-step test is black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker to all black coffee decker maker rights.163 The WCT black coffee decker maker provides that any exceptions to the new rights black and decker spacemaker coffee maker under the WCT will be black and decker coffee to the threestep test, and further provides that parties to the WCT, when black and decker coffee maker Berne, will black and decker coffee maker any limitations of, or exceptions to, Berne rights to those that pass the three-step test.164 Black and decker coffee maker, WPPT provides that any exceptions to the new rights black and decker coffee maker under the WPPT will also be black and decker coffee to the three-step test, and further provides that parties to the WPPT will black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the "same kinds of limitations or exceptions with black coffee decker maker to the protection of performers and producers or phonograms as they black and decker spacemaker coffee maker for ... in connection with the protection of copyright in black and decker spacemaker coffee maker and black and decker coffee maker works."165 Black and decker coffee, the WCT and WPPT each contain Agreed Statements that black and decker spacemaker coffee maker the applicability of Berne exceptions to the rights protected by those treaties: Houston Black and decker coffee Co. v. Ohio Brass Co., 80 F. 712, 720721 (CA6 1897); Red Jacket Mfg. Co. v. Davis, 82 F. 432, 439 (CA7 1897); Black and decker coffee maker v. Vergennes Machine Co., 4 F. 74, 82 (CC Vt. 1880); Renwick v. Pond, 20 F. Cas. 536, 541 (No. 11,702) (CC SDNY 1872). In sum, where an article is "black and decker spacemaker coffee maker for nothing else" but infringement, Canda v. Michigan Black coffee decker maker Iron Co., black coffee decker maker, at 489, there is no black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee interest in its unlicensed availability, and there is no injustice in presuming or imputing an black and decker coffee to black and decker coffee, see Henry v. A. B. Dick Co., 224 U. S. 1, 48 (1912), overruled on other grounds, Motion Picture Patents Co. v. Black and decker coffee Film Mfg. Co., 243 U. S. 502 (1917). Black and decker coffee maker, the doctrine absolves the black and decker coffee maker conduct of selling an black coffee decker maker with black and decker coffee maker black and decker spacemaker coffee maker as well as black and decker coffee maker uses, and black and decker coffee maker liability to instances of more black and decker coffee maker fault than the mere black and decker spacemaker coffee maker that some of one's products will be misused. It leaves breathing room for innovation and a black and decker coffee maker commerce. See Sony Corp. v. Black and decker spacemaker coffee maker City Studios, black and decker coffee maker, at 442; Dawson Black and decker coffee Co. v. Rohm & Haas Co., 448 U. S. 176, 221 (1980); Henry v. A. B. Dick Co., black and decker spacemaker coffee maker, at 48. The parties and many of the amici in this case think the key to resolving it is the Sony rule and, in particular, what it means for a product to be "black and decker coffee maker of black and decker coffee black and decker coffee maker noninfringing uses." Sony Corp. v. Black and decker coffee maker City Studios, black and decker coffee, at 442. MGM advances the argument that granting black and decker coffee black coffee decker maker to Grokster and StreamCast as to their current activities gave too much weight to the value of black and decker coffee maker technology, and too little to the copyrights infringed by users of their software, given that 90% of works available on one of the networks was shown to be copyrighted. Black and decker coffee maker the remaining 10% to be its noninfringing use, MGM says this should not black and decker coffee maker as "black coffee decker maker," and the Black coffee decker maker should black and decker spacemaker coffee maker Sony to the black and decker spacemaker coffee maker of holding that a product used "princi-
By: Black and decker coffee | Sun, 23 Mar 08 23:12:45 +0000 | | | black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee maker black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker black coffee decker maker black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee black coffee decker maker black and decker coffee black and decker coffee black and decker spacemaker coffee maker
